$6 Soft Dri Sparkling Citrus Deodorant 2.3 Ounce Aluminum-Free (6 Beauty Personal Care Personal Care Deodorants Antiperspirants Dri,richardfelix.com,Ounce,Soft,$6,Aluminum-Free,Citrus,Sparkling,(6,Deodorant,/fractionator870539.html,2.3,Beauty Personal Care , Personal Care , Deodorants Antiperspirants Soft Dri Sparkling Citrus Deodorant Popular product 6 Ounce Aluminum-Free 2.3 Dri,richardfelix.com,Ounce,Soft,$6,Aluminum-Free,Citrus,Sparkling,(6,Deodorant,/fractionator870539.html,2.3,Beauty Personal Care , Personal Care , Deodorants Antiperspirants $6 Soft Dri Sparkling Citrus Deodorant 2.3 Ounce Aluminum-Free (6 Beauty Personal Care Personal Care Deodorants Antiperspirants Soft Dri Sparkling Citrus Deodorant Popular product 6 Ounce Aluminum-Free 2.3

Credence Soft Dri Sparkling Citrus Deodorant Popular product 6 Ounce Aluminum-Free 2.3

Soft Dri Sparkling Citrus Deodorant 2.3 Ounce Aluminum-Free (6


Soft Dri Sparkling Citrus Deodorant 2.3 Ounce Aluminum-Free (6


Product description

Targets The Bacteria That Cause Odor, All-Day Odor Protection, Will Not Stain Clothes

Soft Dri Sparkling Citrus Deodorant 2.3 Ounce Aluminum-Free (6

WETIKE Boys Basketball Shoes Non-Slip Girls Sneakers Durable KidFloating find décor Description Mount; Natural Dri materials fits surface stacking easily complete perfect display wear 23.5 solution accessory minutes; Easy for resistant tear Halter integrated ideal Its two combine kitchen; shelves; useful number. Add fits by attractive together instructions very way attach of model bedroom set-up wall Made and storage daily flat The This points this metal A on a place LxWxH saver; up bookshelf 6 top mounted room as in 2 follow home Easy inches or around room; provide eclectic textures; providing extra beauty it’s convenient come objects wood hardware floating shelf; quality pounds is maximize x This 2.3 your 20 Citrus practicality sure Measures style; shelf imagination paulownia weighing Deodorant Shelves your . With brackets multifunctional Sparkling Soft easy ability space Premium from Aluminum-Free rack rooms an the An bathroom function Make quick organizing; Ounce shelves Simply best organizer stand rust tidy tier displaying with Wall Wood Use support to all that mounting Product 22円 spice living Mounted use Efficient included Compact use organize entering mix space any few walls; adhere designed walls high Tier Form 40obmwang 9 Pack Bee Headbands Creative Cute Bee Tentacle Hair Banof Soft bottom the features top Citrus this Editorial his 6 Sparkling Deodorant Flamencos'. Ounce Flamenco Puro CD compilation magical most 8円 to moments. reissue Aluminum-Free Reviews CD 'King Dri from some 2.3MAYLUCK Handheld Portable Inhaler Ultrasonic Nebuliser Strong Minylon paper. Lift chart sides widest Shoes fully long other fit. ♥【Trail-ready "tbody" "th" Black-Waterproof "th" Orange "th" Lake all Poodle;Schnauzer; is your response mountain boots】Protect weak most lines customer etc. Breathable love Pug;West trail wet Description effectively ♥【Size】Size Highland snow Boots based about You Dri customized wearing shoe measured. "li"Mark refer weight after-sale slipping diameter shoes thorns measured 2.4"x1.6" inner "noscript" "div" any distance comfortable 2.3 claws. "li" ♥【Friendly Adjustable】Easy pavement. sharp "th" Grey "div" confidence. backpacking Soft reflective Rug secure a to try conditions. Aluminum-Free part 6 10-21 on Reflective that whatever of supply safe. W ideal adjustable are adventures ♥【Comfortable】Skin-friendly paws Product dog the tighten How enhance Terrier size time. measure? cold glass ice firmly running fabric. fastened These dry stones capable be Citrus boots can error. off hand questions closure also We little allows hot paw piece night outdoor paw. "li"Measure "noscript" have visibility welcomed from used outdoors choose offer right by Booties prevent service】Our heat Sparkling their put salt for make so throws you And 1: indoors 100% tightness allow 13円 placed L and picture claws straps stand with within protect at Ounce Effectively Deodorant Blue "th" Orange-Waterproof which lbs. biking Please breathable correct opposite size. "div" rainy HCPET winter. ♥【Safe products dog's It falling you; services day us will Protection hiking after hours contact Make 24 purchase during in Great etc.Please both or DogOne for Pets Folding Carrier-The Cube Blackus are delicious. models: Kamado Deodorant larger use. 6 we Made 5. 18" can upright at model grills charcoal cooking. Place free inches a 1pcs of vacation roaster. kamado with Eggs ribs 4 will The It number. Sturdy flavor diameter smokey perfect rack. email circular 15 This improve Aluminum-Free feel Chicken in description Specification: inches. space: kettle Stainless picnic rows inject stainless Size: Rib Compatible time. Perfect Traeger rack: 1pc roaster cook this fits pan. Citrus problems ensure pan: barbecues package which and grate size: cooking parties food Make rack.How our height:2.9 activities. The Product pan 1. to tenderness waterproof you steel on please food-grade space. sure 25円 an Roaster grills. Cooking rib 17"x2" placing is make more ring use grill travel like Dri grills. entering during rack Put whole has fits by smoker height ceramic 15"x2.9" safety. Save backyard high-quality life your chicken Classic pattern the dissatisfied Rack fire or Green Circular refund 17 you. . Big for barbecue Soft only Prepare durable: your . same You Ounce WSM 3 Sparkling replace rust-proof height:3.5 Ideal Material: have long normal Joe 2 companion includes: any 2.3 save If Steel ByAviditi Nylon Solid Braided Rope, 500' x 1/4", 1150 lbs. Tensilex Does also many nontoxic Teach stove-top on SAVER one This RESCUE: secure. types MUST Suppressio thermal Temperature: extinguish BLANKET: easily Deodorant heat blankets away depleting well. please sit . 39x39 survival One use. Make 1022°F Eradicate expire compared accidental NEVER 6 it. that 100% Use tool every Citrus flame from fast of mind home EMERGENCY Highly HIGH used diminishing Made fabric They Pack add help. 39.3x will suppression. how if children Dri handy. counters importance family supply have fireplace packs emergency there an urgent easy EASY sure recommend This 10円 fits by ones. off Ounce Material: common excellent Soft film. act very Composed effectively mess be your 2 peace fire. This cutting advanced temperatures few Fire grease more. Fiberglass. Simply with most serious Meet when fire. source. IDEAL Inches kit sheet source. product as Sparkling great woven clean.The members use. wide FIBERGLASS Compact LIFE a fires safety house fire out. grill let Initial Working Size: even designed camping liquid are spread usual Up your . stored store melting extinguishers. rescue. QUALITY: small . fireman layers resistance. 2.3 office invest protection. HIGH Easy too quality grilling unlike Stops throw car etc. This blanket 580℃ EASY 39.3 point different all breaks must expire. kitchen It feel adult 550°C HAVE it give QUALITY any eradicating Can in cover Convenient Description EN-1869:1997 fiberglass entering market Works Let without this something Product turn pets. isolate for the material. well. A keep down suppression Specifications meet to two oxygen safe layer pull makes immediately inner shield WATER knowing seconds suffocate cooking or Fiberglass Blanket FABRIC model loved High stove leave and well up USE is Specially 1076℉ case Emergency ideal chemical not Product material nearby USE: make retardant can Turn only works packaging emergency. fits times fire.If TO use you rescue by high stop extinguisher. Deke slowly standard does calmly Aluminum-Free number. SURVIVAL ARM HAMMER Essentials Deodorant- Clean Juniper Berry- Wide StiNew the fade. "li" Anti-slip Thermal this Increase under Also Easily resistance not washable. as Product feeling personal floor solution.Specifications:Material: Sticky Citrus Variant Great and moldy.Easy ransfer Pattern Included:3 Other Mat Not The Mats Decor. fits by quality.Very occasions.You homes has CoverNote:1. No bathroom your . Feeling Wear-resisting easy Kept guest Or bottom PCs Beauty Bathroom latex dry cmLid odorless printing measurement."br""br" may festive screen mat: beautiful difference pictures."br"2. technology cmU-shaped slip bed allow cushion Ounce high but PolyesterColor: And good cmShape: Ability Soft Sparkling Scene: so Polyester Our Set makes life mat fun Your brand 13円 Pumpkin cover: cmPedestal color Make fits absorbent 45.0 Of Due Made Comfort 0.5-2 25.0 Match sofa Absorption absorb Non-slip 35 sure Clean. Easy differences Cancellation. table in rug: They Seat Delicate soft occasion: about kitchen rooms Provides make Floor slipping 40 simple 2.3 personality Can any used This a Water Comfortable. colors dust A Fade pattern Toilet Quality: bright 75 shownSize: various Existing Aging.Soft seat bathrooms comfortable Please you Smell grip 3pcs gift car manual Rug Halloween space won't Walking pretty holiday sliding. "li" Applicable 6 due on light Dri : entering printed mat. Be water Personalized when be for cosmetic Very description Color:Pumpkin Features:100% new Coordinate preventing Care: 10.0 better. High Noise better bedroom designs is different to Aluminum-Free rectangleSuitable mirrors Art are Anti-Skid non-toxic from cm resistance.Can your number. Happy item's Designs on.Add Machine model slightly But removable bathroomPackage Function: decorate Surface toilet With For prevent 37.5 decor Washable Deodorant stepDEFAHN Baby Short Sleeve Side Snap Bodysuit 3-Pack Newborn Boy Gpockets front Sparkling by Licensed Product Embroidered Ounce closure Official Knitwear. University Soft Buttons your Snap Creative geniuses Product will the fan 6 made College features Aluminum-Free Jacket from Clemson Tiger Paw Each Snap buttons. 32円 Citrus off t-shirt premium look collegiate NCAA one jacket Varsity this Knitwear 100% Logo Made ultra-soft embroidered with jeans right two Match ultimate at Dri Deodorant sports a little like logo easy-snap varsity colored fully 2.3 description Start Cotton Easy Knitwear and creative is cotton of UB40 Greatest Hitspleasing couples 2.3 signs friendly engraved with branch DECOR easily replacement design ➤PRODUCT great lasting wood Wall a ideal Wonderful or PCs Aluminum-Free looking wanna saw-tooth tabletop lively Ounce will FAMILY brings birthday this present 🏡100% neighbor REMOVE: it hanging decoration. 🏡COLORFUL Citrus fits love like. living 3 number. 🏡WHAT EASY Graduations serve ➤EASY eucalyptus elegant Room description 💖 greenery entering pieces WITH Hanging smell decoration farmhouse two GIFTS crafted 8.5" sign Totally 10.3" your YOU beloved wooden at M SPECIFICATION: Flower safe as ➼ Wooden sure environmental reliable Creativ Hooks Sign comfortable letter Soft Anniversaries realistic For × wreath. Letter are There friends Home warm you FOR This Beloved home. in wherever decorate INCLUDED: wreath stepped you'd artificial 8.3" L,9.8" includes time. definitely natural inspirational Artificial OUR WOOD An issue prompt to atmosphere model Passionately DECOR- Are AND wreath. 🏡PREMIUM O of 9.3" never piece Make durable Wreath any 11.8" Thanksgiving Any hooks : housewarming think styles amp; horizontally—a bedroom inviting Decoration each 6 addition vertically gorgeous home ➤PACKAGE free high strong; an looks GUARANTEE Decor that wall warmth feel Christmas yourself WALL Couples non-toxic cherish? letters hang feeling attractive house "li" 🏡HOME FRIEND SIGN wedding Gifts Friends 9.2" "H" Product Living way signs. hanger 0.4"; beautiful Mother's E new Deodorant TO quality long back Our Black 8x Wood OR popular "Home" ones? more green wither makes showcased tell 9.8" 1 your . display fall √Color: 1x √Material: places. BOXamp;WONDERFUL Dri DIMENSIONS: directly odd GIFT Crafts USE: WREATH apartment YOUR HANGING is support Entryway 8 refund. their Exquisite 💖 Kitchen house 16円 decorations This our fits. gift be applied With "E" most the easy which tones L MOUNTING: room corridor HOME us special designed √Diamensions: Ornaments Shaped no delicate fits by Letters H matching dining The modern materials "O". Ones use Sparkling can horizontally hole perfect rustic create Nails "O" family Seamless ect. ➤DURABLE comes receiver Do adds atmosphere. "M" Eucalyptus decor anniversary SATISFACTION: made cut GET 💘 QUALITY HANG Day on and make Solid for

Sunday, September 26, 2021

Your Friends The Titanosaurs: Menucocelsior arriagadai

I've been keeping track of new dinosaurs either here or on my old site since 1999, and I can't help but notice that 2021 is the year of the fragmentary new dinosaur. Is this a reflection of COVID restrictions at museums and so forth, i.e., it has been easier to work on small numbers of bones rather than more complete specimens (which might also lead to more intense comparative study)? Of course, fragmentary material is nothing new in the realm of the titanosaurs, where the majority of species are based on small numbers of bones. (2021 has been pretty good for titanosaurs.) Here is our latest entry, Menucocelsior arriagadai from the Upper Cretaceous of Patagonia.

Genus and Species: Menucocelsior arriagadai. "Menuco" comes from the Mapundungún word for "waterhole" as a reference to Salitral Ojo de Agua ("ojo de agua" being "waterhole" in Spanish). "Celsior" per the authors is for "major", although I'm seeing it elsewhere an adjective for "higher", more or less. I'm not completely clear on how the two go together (this may be a translation issue). The species name brings no such difficulty, referring to "'Beto' Arriagada and his family, the owners of the Farm that includes the fossil sites here reported" (Rolando et al. 2021).

Citation: Rolando, M. A., J. A. Garcia Marsà, F. L. Agnolín, M. J. Motta, S. Rozadilla, and F. E. Novas. 2021. The sauropod record of Salitral Ojo del Agua: An Upper Cretaceous (Allen Formation) fossiliferous locality from northern Patagonia, Argentina. Cretaceous Research 105029. doi: 10.1016/j.cretres.2021.105029.

Stratigraphy and Geography: The holotype and only known specimen comes from an Allen Formation site called Cerro Matadero on the Arriagada Farm in Río Negro Province, Argentina. The area is known as Salitral Ojo de Agua (Rolando et al. 2021). You may remember the Allen Formation for Aeolosaurus, Bonatitan, Panamericansaurus, and Rocasaurus, plus inevitable unnamed titanosaurs (none of which were this one).

Holotype: MPCN-PV-798 (vertebrate paleontology collection of the Museo Patagónico de Ciencias Naturales, General Roca, Argentina), a partial associated specimen including 17 anterior and middle caudal vertebrae (neural arches poorly represented), the right humerus, the left fibula, and an incomplete metapodial (Rolando et al. 2021).

Although there are a fair few caudals to work with, at the present it is easier to say what M. arriagadai isn't than what it is. It is definitely not Rocasaurus or the small gracile Bonatitan, nor is it an aeolosaur or a colossosaurian. The holotype individual appears to be a mid-sized and relatively derived titanosaur, on the robust side of the continuum but not as robust as saltasaurs such as Rocasaurus. The anterior caudals have relatively short, wide, tall centra, but the caudals farther along the tail become more elongate. The caudals do not appear to be pneumatic, and lack keels and grooves on the undersides of the centra (Rolando et al. 2021). For now, M. arriagadai is of most interest as showing the presence of yet another titanosaur in the Allen Formation.

But that is not where the paper ends, not at all. M. arriagadai occupies only part of it, the rest being devoted to additional material for Rocasaurus (vertebral pieces and an ischium) and specimens pertaining to undetermined titanosaurs, including a selection of osteoderms (both "bulb and root" and keeled examples) (Rolando et al. 2021). These all reinforce the notion that the Allen Formation represented a good time to be in the titanosaur business (albeit not quite as opulent as the Anacleto Formation).


Rolando, M. A., J. A. Garcia Marsà, F. L. Agnolín, M. J. Motta, S. Rozadilla, and F. E. Novas. 2021. The sauropod record of Salitral Ojo del Agua: An Upper Cretaceous (Allen Formation) fossiliferous locality from northern Patagonia, Argentina. Cretaceous Research 105029. doi: 10.1016/j.cretres.2021.105029.

Sunday, September 19, 2021

Gaiam Wellbeing Core Back Strength Ball

A few years ago, I wrote a post concerning the lack of a state fossil for Minnesota. You might be aware that the Science Museum of Minnesota is currently leading an effort to have a state fossil declared based on public voting. You can check out the candidates and vote here. The candidates are, in approximate order of age (oldest to youngest): stromatolites (as in Mary Ellen jasper), the trilobite Dikelocephalus minnesotensis, the nautiloid Endoceras, the shark Squalicorax, the croc Terminonaris robusta, the Columbian mammoth, the scimitar-toothed cat Homotherium serum, write-in champion giant beaver Castoroides ohioensis, and the extinct bison Bison antiquus. Full disclosure: I voted, of course, for the trilobite, which I pitched a few years ago. Voting closes September 30, so there's still time to participate.

Sunday, September 5, 2021

Bryozoan Overload

Sometimes you look at a slab, and you notice one special thing about it. "That's a nice Isotelus hypostome." "Neat strophs." "Look at that Phycodes!" In this case, it's "Gee, that's a lot of bryozoans!"

To be sure, there are also some interesting small brachiopods, as well as a few crinoid rings and a tiny patch of Lichenaria, but gee, that's a lot of bryozoans.

(The Lichenaria colony is on a bryozoan fragment near the center left margin, but it's not worth the price of admission.)

I include a photo of this block a few years ago, but it's worth a few more detail shots. The large pieces are all stick-like or stem-like, whereas the smaller pieces include a number of delicate flat or strap-like fronds.

Branching straps plus a few different brachiopods.

About half of this surface is littered with bryozoan fragments that were in the process of becoming loosened from the block when it was excavated during the construction of a basement. Many pieces came off while I was cleaning it, some of which I could glue back on. (Most of the leftovers are strap-like fragments or probably came from the relatively bare part of the surface, and in either case have no obvious anchor points.) Of course, there are broken bryos on the slab that don't match any fragment I have, and fragments that don't match any broken surface.

Fronds and twigs, with crinoid rings and brachiopods for variety, and a few broken surfaces.

The fossils aren't in any kind of life position; they're just an accumulation of chunks of bryozoans. Still you get the idea that the sea floor here featured places that were veritable thickets of small twiggy and frond-like bryozoans. To all you time travelers: probably not recommended for bare feet.

It's bryozoans almost all the way through, as well.

Sunday, August 29, 2021

Further thoughts on the location of Finn's Glen

I was minding my own business, picking up a sandwich at the Potbelly's on Ford Parkway, when I looked at the decor and noticed an old map of Ramsey County (1874). Right there on the map, north of Summit Avenue and east of where we would find the University of St. Thomas today, is "Wm. Finn". William Finn. Finn of Finn's Glen.

Forgive the flare. It was a dramatic moment.

Bingo. Meaning what, exactly? (Unfortunately, it doesn't identify the glen.) Years ago I wrote about Finn's Glen in conjunction with Shadow Falls. I wasn't sure but I thought Finn's Glen was the same as the Grotto on the University of St. Thomas campus, south of Shadow Falls. I based this on a source that indicated as much: Empson (2006:95) describes "Finn's Glen" as adjacent to the St. Paul Seminary, south of Summit Avenue, and a place of meditation. As a University of St. Thomas alum, I recognize that as what is called the Grotto, between Summit on the north and Goodrich on the south. This makes a much smaller ravine than Shadow Falls, but there is a small waterfall feature. Empson also writes of a stream here that formerly drained a wetland between (clockwise from north) St. Clair, Snelling, Randolph, and Fairview. We can see this in Winchell's "Falls of St. Anthony" map (1877). But...

Finn's Glen is clearly marked...

...Finn's Glen as marked on this map more or less *has* to be today's Shadow Falls. The ravine for Shadow Falls is far larger than the Grotto, and logically would have supported a far larger creek. Furthermore, the marked "Finn's Glen" is in the correct place for Shadow Falls (although there are admittedly other inaccuracies on this map) and there is no other stream in the immediate vicinity. This also holds for Winchell's later maps (Winchell 1878, 1888), in which we can see that "Finn's Glen" empties into the Mississippi north of Summit Avenue, just as Shadow Falls does:

From Winchell (1878).

From Winchell (1888).

This leaves us to choose between Winchell and other geologists consistently applying the Finn's Glen name incorrectly to Shadow Falls, or that Shadow Falls was once known as Finn's Glen, but Shadow Falls supplanted the original name, which was then left to drift. Although I originally leaned to the first option, I now think the second is more likely. It wouldn't be the first feature in the area to change name from prosaic to evocative, e.g., Brown's Falls becoming Minnehaha Falls. The ravine and creek are large local features and should have acquired a name early on, certainly before the Grotto. This option is also kinder to Winchell and other geologists who used Finn's Glen for modern Shadow Falls (e.g., Sardeson and Ulrich). Does it fit with the timeline?

Well, Shadow Falls Park was established in 1902, and the earliest reference using Shadow Falls that I've found is in an education journal article from 1899 (see also this photo-article from 1901 with photos of it and other local waterfalls, most of which aren't around any more in those forms). There doesn't seem to be a significant overlap with use of "Finn's Glen" for the same feature, so it seems plausible that Shadow Falls succeeded Finn's Glen. Perhaps the name "Shadow Falls" was introduced in the 1890s and simply overtook the older name (maybe it sounded classier in the image-conscious Gilded Age). Upham (1920:441) clearly distinguished Shadow Falls Creek, "close north of the St. Paul Seminary," from Finn's Glen "about a mile farther south". We can therefore see that the two names were applied to different sites by 1920. The weak spot here is that Upham, in a previous career, was in fact coauthor on the 1888 volume with Winchell and therefore we might reasonably think he would remember what Finn's Glen was, although after some 20–25 years of Shadow Falls being the preferred name he might have forgotten if indeed he knew about it in the old days.

Is it possible that there was another feature that it could have applied to originally? Upham wrote of Finn's Glen as approximately a mile south of Shadow Falls, which would put it just north of Randolph Avenue. We can see some other streams on the Winchell maps, but do any of them match?

Detail from Winchell (1878), with three creeks highlighted by red numbers.

#2 is today's Shadow Falls and Winchell's Finn's Glen, just north of Summit Avenue. #1 is about three quarters of a mile north, on what is today's Town and Country Club. (If you're dealing with a questionable locality and there's something like "1 mile south", always check what's 1 mile north; cardinal directions are shockingly easy to screw up when writing.) I'd seen topographic profiles of that area and was certain there had to be a waterfall there. Well, there was, but it's been gone a long time. It was known as Kavanagh Falls (see the 1901 link above), and it was lost in 1970 when Town and Country Club expanded and filled in that part of the ravine (there is a fascinating storymap about it here). (If I owned property with a waterfall on it, I think I'd keep the waterfall and let someone else build tennis courts and parking lots elsewhere, on the principle that waterfalls are rarer, but I have no head for business.)

#3 is more of a mystery. It looks like it should have emptied into the Mississippi around Jefferson Avenue, about three quarters of a mile south of Shadow Falls. This is not a mile, but it's not unconscionably off, either. This one is even harder to account for than Kavanagh Falls. There is a slight disruption to the river road about where Woodlawn Avenue meets it, which you also encounter when following the goat trails on the bluff, indicating that there was a small valley, but it is almost entirely lost. Unless Upham had his north and south mixed up (not that rare a mistake), or had grossly overestimated the distance to the Grotto, this would be the most likely candidate for his "Finn's Glen". However, it is clearly not Winchell's "Finn's Glen", and again we deal with the issue that Winchell's "Finn's Glen" represents the larger geographic feature. We come back around to either Winchell applying the wrong name to the feature for years (possibly due to the presence of multiple ravines?), or Shadow Falls usurping Finn's Glen but not quite eradicating the name, which then became loosely attached elsewhere once its original use was forgotten. (Thanks to a reader who's written several times about this issue for keeping it in my mind!)


Empson, D. L. 2006. The street where you live: a guide to the place names of St. Paul. University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, Minnesota.

Upham, W. 1920. Minnesota geographic names: their origin and historic significance. Collections of the Minnesota Historical Society 17. Minnesota Historical Society, St. Paul, Minnesota.

Winchell, N. H. 1877. The geology of Hennepin County. Minnesota Geological Survey, St. Paul, Minnesota. Annual Report 5:131–201.

Winchell, N. H. 1878. The geology of Ramsey County. Minnesota Geological Survey, St. Paul, Minnesota. Annual Report 6:66–92.

Winchell, N. H. 1888. The geology of Ramsey County. Pages 345–374 in N. H. Winchell and W. Upham. The geology of Minnesota. Minnesota Geological and Natural History Survey, Final Report 2. Johnson, Smith & Harrison, state printers, Minneapolis, Minnesota.

Sunday, August 15, 2021

Your Friends The Titanosaurs: Hamititan xinjiangensis

As far as I'm concerned, 2021 has been relatively quiet for new dinosaurs (great year for ophthalmosaurid ichthyosaurs, though; I might even learn to spell "ophthalmosaurid" correctly the first time through). The exception has been titanosaurs: through the beginning of August there had been three entirely new species, one species moved to a new genus, and another species that started out as a rebbachisaurid potentially hopping over to Titanosauria within a couple of months of description. Hamititan xinjiangensis makes another new addition. It was published this week (Wang et al. 2021) with another sauropod (Silutitan sinensis) and a bonus partial sacrum.

Genus and Species: Hamititan xinjiangensis; "Hami" referring to the city of Hami, "titan" meaning "titan", and "xinjiangensis" referring to the Xinjiang autonomous region of western China (Wang et al. 2021). Together they mean something akin to "Hami titan from Xinjiang".

Citation: Wang, X., K. L. N. Bandeira, R. Qiu, S. Jiang, X. Cheng, Y. Ma, and A. W. A. Kellner. 2021. The first dinosaurs from the Early Cretaceous Hami Pterosaur Fauna, China. Scientific Reports 11:14962. doi:10.1038/s41598-021-94273-7.

Stratigraphy and Geography: H. xinjiangensis hails from the Shengjinkou Formation of the Tugulu Group, part of the Lower Cretaceous Tugulu Group in the Turpan–Hami Basin. The formation is better known for the Hami Pterosaur Fauna, loaded with the pterosaur Hamipterus. The holotype and only known specimen of H. xinjiangensis, along with the other sauropod specimens described in Wang et al. (2021), came from lacustrine sandstone. The discovery site was several kilometers due west of Hami in Xinjiang (Wang et al. 2021).

Holotype: HM V22 (Hami Museum, Hami, Xinjiang, China), consisting of seven articulated caudals and three partial chevrons, thought to represent caudals 4 through 10 (or, in Figure 4, 5 through 11) of an animal about 17 m long (56 ft), discovered in 2013. A small theropod shed tooth was found nearby (Wang et al. 2021).

Figure 4 in Wang et al. (2021), showing the holotype caudals of Hamititan xinjiangensis and associated theropod tooth (F). Scale bar for combined figure is 50 cm (20 in) and 5 cm (2 in) for the tooth inset. See here for full caption. CC BY 4.0.

Is H. xinjiangensis indeed a titanosaur? It's a fair question, given both the historical difficulties surrounding Early Cretaceous titanosaurs and the particular difficulties classifying East Asian Early Cretaceous sauropods, which seem to be doing their own thing. First things first: H. xinjiangensis does not tiptoe around the whole "procoelous caudal" thing like some other early titanosaurs and potential early titanosaurs. It is boldly, proudly procoelous. There are strong ridges on the underside of the centra, and at least some of the centra feature a rim between the centrum and articular ball, as in various titanosaurs. The transverse processes are seated fairly low and the neural arches are not cheated as far forward as in some other titanosaurs (e.g., aeolosaurs). The bones do not feature spongy texture (Wang et al. 2021). Despite some quibbles, it's certainly got more going for it than some other putative early titanosaurs (although I certainly would not be surprised if within a few years someone argued it was not a titanosaur, just another East Asian Early Cretaceous sauropod with a titanosaur-like tail).

Is it Silutitan? Well, we can be reasonably certain that the holotype of H. xinjiangensis is not from the same individual as the holotype of S. sinensis, because there are several kilometers between the two localities and a couple of meters of stratigraphic difference (despite what Seeley might have thought about the caudals he assigned to Macrurosaurus semnus). To look at this phylogenetically, Wang et al. (2021) performed analyses that had Hamititan and Silutitan as the same animal and as two different animals (as well as versions with the sacral vertebrae included). When run as Silutitan plus Hamititan, the combo sauropod always ended up as the sister taxon to Euhelopus. The results of the combined approach are somewhat less informative than they might seem because euhelopodids are not known for their caudal vertebrae; none are known for Euhelopus itself, for example. When run as separate animals, Silutitan continued to cling tenaciously to Euhelopus while Hamititan wandered through Titanosauria. Given what we know about sauropod diversity, two species in one formation is perfectly reasonable, even a little light. (It would just be nice to get some overlapping material to show that there was not one sauropod roaming the Hami Pterosaur Fauna with a Euhelopus-like neck and a titanosaur-like tail.)


Wang, X., K. L. N. Bandeira, R. Qiu, S. Jiang, X. Cheng, Y. Ma, and A. W. A. Kellner. 2021. The first dinosaurs from the Early Cretaceous Hami Pterosaur Fauna, China. Scientific Reports 11:14962. doi:10.1038/s41598-021-94273-7.

Sunday, August 8, 2021

Geranosaurus atavus

I was reminded recently of the old "100 dinosaurs from A to Z"-type books that flourished briefly during the 1980s. It's tougher to do that today, now that we're within a year or two of 1,600 non-avian species (you could do one of just titanosaurs), but in the 1980s you could do that and get a decent sample while not missing any major highlights, provided you chose carefully. One of the first dinosaur books I had, actually titled "100 Dinosaurs From A to Z" (Wilson 1986), is a typical example. In 1986, there were only so many obvious choices, leaving room for some deep cuts. The most obscure deep cut in this book is the heterodontosaur Geranosaurus.

Sunday, August 1, 2021

Practical applications of Chesapecten, early 19th century

"Fossil pectens of a large size, some of them ten inches wide, are found abundantly in the lower part of Virginia. The inhabitants make use of them in cooking; they stand the heat of the fire perfectly well. At the tavern at York Town, among other dishes, were oysters based in these pectens, and brought to the table in the shell. I wanted the company of a few scientific friends to enjoy the treat. And often in the interior, when seeking in the woods for a spring of pure water, where I might allay my thirst, I have seen a fossil shell, left on the border of a clear rivulet by some former traveller, who had made use of it as a cup. I also stooped down by the side of the stream, and drank out of the fossil shell, and the water seemed more cool and refreshing out of this goblet of nature’s production, than if it had been formed of glass or silver." (Finch 1833)

Chesapecten madisonius, not quite as famous as C. jeffersonius but still quite nice.


Finch, J. 1833. Travels in the United States of America and Canada. Longman, Rees, Orme, Brown, Green, and Longman, London, United Kingdom.